| Review of the Nokia 5200 |
 |
The Nokia 5200 is a tri-band (850, 1900, and 1800 MHz) slider phone and is presently offered on both Fido and 7-11. It’s a bit cheaper at 7-11, selling for just $150, but you can get it at Fido (with no contract) for $200. It offers an MP3 player with an included 1 GB MicroSD card (which may be replaced with up to a 2 GB card). It also supports A2DP Bluetooth stereo headsets.
The Nokia 5200 is available through 7-11 and Fido. Last Updated: 03-Jun-2008 |
Before reading this review, please read
Some Thoughts on Phone Reviewing.
RF Performance
Click on this link for a full description of
RF Performance, and how to interpret it.
RF Sensitivity: Tests were made of RF performance
at the usual Hall of Shame over at Square One shopping mall. I
compared the ability to pull in a signal during a call against a
Nokia E51 (which I was also reviewing at the time)
and I found it to have excellent RF qualities. Both phones performed almost
identically, and so by extension the 5520 also has excellent RF sensitivity. In
other words, it’s as good as you’re presently going to get at pulling in a
really weak signal.
Note that the 5200 supports only standard GSM, while the E51 also supports
UMTS. The comparisons noted above were made
with the E51 switched to standard GSM mode.
Over-the-road Performance: I was generally pleased
with the phone’s tame handling of constant handoffs during various tests that
were made from a moving car in parts of the city where sites were quite dense.
An important aspect of any 2.5G (that is, non-UMTS) GSM phone is its ability to
make handoff seem as unobtrusive as possible. In this regard the 5200 ranks up
there with the better Nokia models, but I’ve heard slightly better performance
on other makes.
Audio Performance
Click on this link for a full description of
Audio Performance, and how to interpret it.
Tonal Balance: The overall incoming tonal balance
isn’t bad compared to many phones I’d tested (including a number of high-end
Nokia models), but at the same time it falls short of some of the
better-sounding models out there (including my still-current
Motorola i880 on
Telus Mike). The tone of incoming
audio is a little harsh, but not enough to make you want to yank the phone from
your ear or turn down the volume until you can’t hear it.
Sound Reproduction: I was a little disappoint in
this aspect of the phone, in that it seems to add a bit of distortion to the
sound that isn’t there when I made calls to identical sources with other GSM
phones (including my ancient Nokia 6310i). The
distortion isn’t particularly noticeable under day-to-day use however, but Nokia
could have done better.
Earpiece Volume: The volume is acceptable, but
hardly stellar. For example, when I call the same numbers for comparison I must
turn down my i880 volume to 5-out-of-7 to match the volume that comes out of the
5200 at full volume. The i880 is a fairly loud phone, and so this isn’t a
completely fair comparison. However, I’ve tested plenty of other phones recently
that fall only slightly short of the volume generated by the i880.
Outgoing Audio: Outgoing tonal balance is rather
the opposite of incoming. Instead of being harsh, it’s actually a tiny bit
muddy. Overall however, the outgoing sound was extremely good and your voice
will sound quite natural to your caller.
The phone also handles the background noise generated by the people at the
Square One food court at least as well as the E51. I therefore thought that
it would have no trouble with the open-window-on-the-highway test, but I was in
for a rather nasty shock. I’ve tested many phones that do poorly when exposed to
the rushing wind noise of an open car window at highway speeds, but none behaved
quite as oddly as the 5200.
Prior to opening the window the quality of my voice was exceptional (as
expected), but the moment the window was opened my voice turned into a garbled
mess that was completely impossible to understand. Howard Chu suggested that the
problem might have been the result of using the Voice Clarity feature,
which is supposed to make the user’s voice sound better under noisy conditions.
We ran the test again with the feature turned off, but the results were no
different.
This is one of the only bad points on what is otherwise a pretty decent phone.
While no Nokia model does well in this particular test, none have done quite so
badly. There are also many phones out there that can pass this test with flying
colors, and so Nokia really doesn’t have a good excuse for the poor performance
under these conditions.
Speakerphone: I’ve often said that there are 2
types of speakerphones on Nokias: those that are too faint to be any use; and
those that are surprisingly loud and clear. The 5200 falls into the latter
category with a really loud (though not particularly clear) speakerphone.
However, as with virtually all Nokias I’ve tested (regardless of the quality of
their speakerphone implementations) the 5200 is much better at playing music and
the audio track of videos than it is at playing the voice of an incoming caller.
I’ve never understood why this is so, because other companies don’t seem to have
the same problem. The 5200 is no different, but the upshot is that the audio for
playing MP3 files through the built-in speaker is extremely good.
On the 5200 that I tested, the speakerphone suffered from large doses of what
sounded like sympathetic vibrations in the plastic housing of the phone. This
makes the audio sound oddly distorted unless the volume is turned down.
Surprisingly however, no such vibrations seem present when playing MP3 files
through the speaker, even at full volume.
Support Features
Ringer Volume: With the correctly-chosen ringtone
the volume is much better than many other phones on the market. This isn’t to
say that it’s as loud as a typical iDEN phone like my i880, but compared to the
bulk of phones I’ve reviewed in the last few years the 5200 is remarkable
audible under typically harsh conditions (such as noisy streets and in crowded
shopping malls).
Keypad Design: Because the 5200 is a slider design,
it has plenty of space for a good-quality 12-key pad. The keys are nicely
spaced, plus you can feel where they are without looking at them courtesy of a
raised bump in the middle of each key. The tactile feel of each key as it is
pressed is also very good, making this one of the better keypads I’d ever seen
on a slider phone.
Unfortunately the remaining keys (on the top of the phone) aren’t quite up to
the standards of the slide-out 12-key pad. The 2 softkeys and the TALK and END
buttons are okay, but the 4-way cursor pad and selection button have poor feel
and are error-prone, especially for people with big fingers. Various other Nokia
slider models use slightly different 4-way pads that much better than the one on
the 5200.
Display: The color display of the 5200 is 128 x 160
pixels supporting only 256 colors. It’s also not a TFT type of display common on
many other phones, which means that the colors are more washed-out and the
contrast is poorer. However, the advantage of the CSTN display is that it works
incredibly well in bright sunlight. Under intense light most TFT displays rely
solely upon the backlight to make the pixels visible, whereas a CSTN display can
reflect light that passes through the display. The brighter the light gets, the
easier it is to see. Note that in my review of the E51 I found that the TFT
display on that phone is able to reflect sunlight internally. However, it is
nothing like the reflected light you get on the 5200.
Overall however, for the purposes of providing information concerning phone
calls and the currently-playing MP3 file, the CSTN display is more than adequate
in low-light conditions too. It may not have the brilliance and clarity of a
top-notch TFT display, but for what it’s intended to do, the CSTN display of the
5200 is pretty darned good.
Icing on the Cake
Camera: The camera in the 5200 is just a simple 640
x 480 implementation that’s really there for just two purposes: to take picture
ID shots and to send as MMS to another phone. You certainly wouldn’t use it to
take real photographs.
MP3 Player: The music player in the 5200 is hardly
competition for the iPod, but it has many useful features such as an equalizer
and sorting based on song title, artist name, genre, or album title. It runs as
a foreground or background application, which means that you can continue to use
the phone as normal while the music plays in the background. If you make a call,
or if a call comes in, the playback is paused and can be restarted from where
you left off after the call is over. It also includes limited functionality for
creating playlists, but the support doesn’t seem to be all that great. The phone
comes with a 1 GB MicroSD card and you can upgrade that to a 2 GB card if you
want to store more music.
The sound quality of the music through stereo earbuds or through an A2DP (stereo
Bluetooth) headset is very good, and when you play the audio through the
built-in speaker the overall quality and volume is surprisingly good. Certainly
don’t expect any bass, but other than that the music is very listenable through
the tiny little speaker.
Conclusions
With a few notable exceptions the 5200 is a fairly decent phone. It has loads of
features, reasonably good overall performance, a useable speakerphone, and a MP3
player. The outgoing audio is useless in a noisy vehicle, but other than that it
sounds great.
If you buy this phone through 7-11 in Canada you’ll get a really good deal. They
sell the 5200 for just $150, and it’s UNLOCKED. Over at Fido they want $200
without a contract and the phone they sell you is LOCKED to Fido. While I’m sure
that neither the Fido nor 7-11 people aren’t going to like me suggesting this,
but if you want a 5200 to use on Fido, buy it through a 7-11 store instead. You
can even get a few bucks selling the 7-11 SIM card that comes with the phone.
